Iasb ed20191 interest rate benchmark reform proposed amendments to ifrs 9 and ias 39 efrags feedback statement detailed analysis of issues, comments received and changes made to efrags final comment letter efrags tentative views expressed in the draft comment letter and. Comment letters are public and all comment letters received on the due process. Phase one the first phase of amendments to ifrs 9, ias 39 and ifrs 7 focused on hedge accounting issues related to uncertainties arising in the period leading up to the replacement of ibor. Deloitte comment letter on ifric tentative agenda decision. Recognition and measurement, notably by introducing the expected loss model. Comment letter on ed201511 applying ifrs 9 financial instruments with.
Henry rees project manager international accounting standards. In this study, we read and analyze 369 comment letters written in response to the iasbs exposure draft ed of proposed amendments to ias 37 and the fasbs exposure draft of proposed amendments. Cruf letter to iasb re ifrs 17 insurance contracts. Comment letter exposure draft of amendments to ias 32. The final amendments were issued in september 2019 and amended specific hedge accounting requirements to provide relief from potential effects of the. Henry rees project manager international accounting. Proposed amendments to ifrs 9, ias 39, ifrs 7, ifrs 4 and ifrs 16.
Aug 27, 2019 comments on and responses to the exposure draft on interest rate benchmark reform proposed ammendments to ifrs 9 and ias 39. The comment letters received in response to the request for information on the feasibility of. Ifrs 9 financial instruments and ias 39 financial instruments. Exclude financial instruments accounted for in accordance with ifrs 9, rather than ias 39. You will find here the comment letters sent by mazars to the iasb, the ifrs interpretations committee and other standard setting or regulatory bodies. Sec comment letters on foreign private issuers using ifrss. Sec comment letters on foreign private issuers using. Amortised cost and impairment the new york state society of certified public accountants thanks the international accounting standards board the board for the opportunity to comment on the exposure draft financial instruments. Comment letters to the iasb, the ifric and other standard. These are usually in the form of discussion papers and exposure drafts, and the results of the feedback we receive will determine which direction the project will take. This feedback statement summarises the main comments received by efrag on its draft comment letter and explains how those comments were considered. The draft interpretation had proposed to clarify that the assessment under ias 39 of when an embedded derivative is to be separated from its host contract is made when the entity first becomes a party to the contract and is not reassessed.
The committee should therefore consider the question of whether it is appropriate to adjust the effective interest rate in these cases, as leaving it unresolved may lead to significant diversity in practice. Iasb ed ed20191 interest rate benchmark reform proposed amendments to. Three levels of reliability level 1,2 and 3 level 1. Ias 19the limit on a defined benefit asset, minimum funding requirements and their interaction analysis of matters raised in comment letters on the proposed amendments agenda papers 3, 3a, 3b, 3c, 3d and 3e ifrs 9. We also believe that the iasb should provide further guidance regarding the application of ias 38 to. Ias 36 impairment of assets prescribes the procedures to apply to ensure assets are carried at no more than their recoverable amount. Abbreviations iasb structure members of the iasb iasb due process. Comment letter 1 ed leases letter to the iasb on the exposure draft leases pdf. Comment letter to the ifrs ic tad on ias 39ifrs 9 esma. Deloitte comment letter on the iasbs proposed amendments to ias 1 and the materiality practice statement. Recognition and measurement this fact sheet is based on existing requirements as at 31 december 2015 and does not take into account recent standards and interpretations that have been issued but are not yet effective. Tentative agenda decision and comment lettersias 32 centrally cleared client derivatives consultation. The ifric received several comment letters explaining an interpretation of ias 39 that is commonly used in practice. The accounting standard ias 39 sets out the principles for recognising and measuring financial assets, financial liabilities and some contracts to buy or sell nonfinancial items.
The iasb, successor to the international accounting standards committee, has played a central role in this process and numerous countries now require or permit the use of international financial reporting standards ifrs. The international accounting standards board board has published for public comment proposed changes to the old and new financial instruments standards, ias 39 and ifrs 9, in light of the reform of interest rate benchmarks such as interbank offer rates ibors. This is regarded by many as the most complex of all. Furthermore, esma firmly believes that it is of the utmost importance that the amendments to ifrs 4 do not create any uncertainties in the implementation process of ifrs 9 as in our view, application of ifrs 9. Ias 28 investments in associates and joint ventures 15 5. Comment letters to the iasb, the ifric and other standard setting or. Ias 36 impairment of assets ifrs standards tracker icaew. Requirements for presenting information about financial instruments are in. Discount rate for employee benefits, proposed amendments. Press release issued by the iasb on 24 july 2014 announcing the publication of ifrs 9 financial instruments, which will replace requirements within ias 39 covering classification and measurement, impairment, hedge accounting and derecognition. The iasbs exposure draft applying ifrs 9 financial. The sd is an important part of the replacement of ias 39. In its third phase of the project to replace ias 39 financial instruments.
Since 2003, the iasb has issued the following amendments to ias 39. Comment letters iasb 30 cannon street london ec4m 6xh united kingdom. Icpau comment letters institute of certified public. Under that interpretation, entities that enter into short sales of securities are allowed to choose trade date or settlement date accounting. You will find here the comment letters sent by mazars to the iasb, the ifrs. Exposure draft ed20202 covid19related rent concessions proposed amendment to ifrs 16 30 april 2020.
At some key stages in our projects we publish documents which are open for public comment. We support this approach, which provides more time to develop the new macro hedging model whilst allowing the general hedge accounting requirements to be finalised and made available for use at the earliest opportunity. Recognition and measurement frequently asked questions faq see also ip0485 how are decisions taken in the european union to adopt international financial reporting standards ifrs. Pdf a content analysis of the comment letters to the fasb. Recognition and measurement this basis for conclusions accompanies, but is not part of, ias 39. Comment letters, 2011 dear sir or madam, financial. Recognition and measurementmarch 2019 the committee received a request about the requirement in ifrs 9 and ias 39 that a forecast transaction must be highly probable to qualify as a hedged item in a cash flow hedge relationship. Proposed amendments to ifrs 9, ias 39, ifrs 7, ifrs 4 and ifrs 16 comments due by 25 may 2020 exposure draft and comment letters.
Find articles, books and online resources providing quick links to the standard, summaries, guidance and news of recent developments. The afrac financial instruments working group prepares comment letters on. Application of the highly probable requirement when a specific derivative is designated as a hedging instrument ifrs 9 financial instruments and ias 39 financial instruments. Effective date, comparatives and early adoption the board does not normally state in an exposure draft an expected effective date of a final standard. Hedging instrument ifrs 9 financial instruments and ias 39 financial instruments. Recognition and measurementmarch 2019 the committee received a request about the requirement in ifrs 9 and ias 39 that a forecast transaction.
Title comment due by iscas comment letters to iasb. Tips for searching the secs comment letter database. We appreciate the opportunity to comment on the exposure draft. Specifically, practice recognises the short sales as. Comment letter for amendments to ias 39 fair value option. Ias 38 intangible assets 89 ias 39 financial instruments. Efrag published its final comment letter on the iasb ed20191 interest rate benchmark reform proposed amendments to ifrs 9 and ias 39 the ed on 20 june 2019. Iasb ed20191 interest rate benchmark reform proposed. Our aim is to illuminate one of the leastunderstood and mostfeared aspects of ifrs. Further information on the project and the proposed model is available at. Recognition and measurement, with a comment deadline of 14 october 2002. We welcome the boards decision to retain a time proportionate recognition approach of the expected credit losses on the good book. Embedded derivatives proposed amendments to ifric 9. Disclosure and presentation and ias 39 financial instruments.
The board has proposed to amend ifrs 9 financial instruments and ias 39 financial instruments. Paragraph 103a proposes that an entity that adopts early the december 2003 version of ias 39 may change the financial assets and financial liabilities designated as at fair value through profit or loss from the beginning of the first period for which it adopts the amendments in this exposure draft. General presentation and disclosures primary financial statements. Ias 39 and ifrs 9 provide a helpful framework for evaluating the. A clear majority of the overall financial statement comments focused on the ifrs financial statements. Members of the international accounting standards board. Ias 39 is applicable for annual reporting periods commencing on or after 1 january 2005 and will be superseded by ifrs 9 financial instruments for annual periods beginning on or after 1 january 2018. Publications accounting guides ifrs news in brief in depth in the loop pwc comment letters pwc point of view sec comment letter trends the quarter close weekly newsletter podcasts, webcasts and videos pwc s accounting podcast webcasts videos ondemand cpe. Recognition and measurement to provide relief from specific. Deloitte comment letters to the iasb and numerous other bodies.
Bc11a some of the comment letters on the june 2002 exposure draft and participants in. The committee should therefore consider the question of whether it is appropriate to adjust the effective interest rate in these cases, as leaving it unresolved may. Deposits relating to taxes other than income tax ias 37 provisions. The european securities and markets authority esma thanks.
Tweet technical summary of ias 39 financial instruments. Comment letter on exposure draft ed20191 interest rate benchmark. Ifrs 9 as it is considered an improvement over ias 39 financial. In december 2003 the iasb issued a revised ias 39, accompanied by implementation guidance replacing that published by the former igc. A content analysis of the comment letters to the fasb and iasb. The iasbs supplementary document on the exposure draft. In august 2003 the board published a further exposure draft of proposed amendments to ias 39 on fair value hedge accounting for a portfolio hedge of interest rate, risk with a comment. The objective of this standard is to establish principles for recognising and measuring financial assets, financial liabilities and some contracts to buy or sell nonfinancial items. We are frequently asked to provide our perspective on the topics the sec staff focuses on in its comment letters to registrants. Ifrs 9 and ias 39 derecognition of modified financial assets.
Bc3 because the board did not reconsider the fundamental approach to the accounting for financial instruments established by ias 32 and ias 39, this basis. Whilst we agree that it is useful to replace significant by material, we are concerned that without further guidance, the assessment of whether an accounting policy is material may be driven primarily by quantitative considerations. Assessment of promised goods or services ifrs 15 revenue from contracts with customers 39 9. Proposed amendments to ifrs 9, ias 39, ifrs 7, ifrs 4 and ifrs 16 16 apr 2020 deloitte comment letter on tentative agenda decision on ias 38 presentation of player transfer payments. Ifrs in focus iasb proposes interest rate benchmark reform phase 2. Comments on the exposure draft and the basis for conclusions should be submitted in writing so as to be received by 11 january 2008. International financial reporting standards ias 39. Business combinations this publication brings together and summarises key guidance that you need to know for the practical application of international financial reporting standards ifrs as they apply to business. In june 2003, the iasb made a limited amendment to ias 39 when it issued ifrs 1 firsttime adoption of international financial reporting standards. Application of the highly probable requirement when a. Specifically, practice recognises the short sales as financial. A content analysis of the comment letters to the fasb and. The board received over 170 comment letters on the exposure draft. Comment letter on exposure draft ed20191 interest rate benchmark reform the ed pdf 86 kb june 2019 iasb.
The 2017 edition of sec comment letters including industry insights offers such perspective. In addition to extracts of letters and links to relevant related resources, it contains analysis. Pdf a content analysis of the comment letters to the. Members of the international accounting standards board performance and priorities 2018 performance 14 2019 priorities 16. International comment letters kpmg global kpmg global. Embedded derivatives proposed amendments to ifric 9 and. Recognition and measurement establishes the principles for the recognition. In our comment letter on the ed we raised concerns about the distinction between short term trade. Embedded derivatives proposed amendments to ifric 9 and ias 39 keywords. As of october 5, 2008, comment letters were received from 127 respondents, summarized below. Tentative agenda decision and comment lettersias 32. Ias 39 application of the effective interest rate method published on. Other respondents suggested that the fasb adopt ias 39 now, or.
Iaasb proposed strategy for 20202023 and work plan for 20202021 pdf 4 kb 31 may 2019 iaasb. We answer the questions we are asked most often by companies applying ias 39, and illustrate how to achieve hedge accounting for a range of hedging strategies commonly used in practice. Exposure draft ed20201 interest rate benchmark reform phase 2 proposed amendments to ifrs 9, ias 39, ifrs 7, ifrs 4 and ifrs 16. Tentative agenda decision and comment lettersias 32 centrally cleared client derivatives. Please visit our standardsetting page or our due process handbook for more detailed. Deposits relating to taxes other than income tax ias 37 provisions, contingent liabilities and contingent assets 41 10. Revenue recognition in a real estate contract that includes the transfer of land. In this study, we read and analyze 369 comment letters written in response to the iasbs exposure draft ed of proposed amendments to ias 37 and the fasbs exposure draft of proposed amendments to fasb statement no. Requirements for presenting information about financial instruments are in ias 32 financial instruments. The proposals may be modified in the light of the comments received before being issued in final form as amendments to ias 39.
702 1002 260 415 541 1132 982 1093 267 1429 1292 1434 1343 1068 668 549 84 1645 386 726 346 72 660 1437 874 176 203 598 973 62 1407